| Nov 1 | Non-Conf | vs. SUNY Brockport | 47–4 | 1-0 | — |
| Nov 1 | Non-Conf | vs. Glenville State | 31–15 | 2-0 | — |
| Nov 1 | Non-Conf | vs. Niagara County CC | 49–0 | 3-0 | — |
| Nov 1 | Non-Conf | vs. Sacred Heart | 36–7 | 4-0 | — |
| Nov 5 | Tourn | Clarion Open | — | — | PennWest Clarion · Clarion, PA |
| Nov 11 | Non-Conf | vs. Long Island | 16–19 | 4-1 | — |
| Nov 11 | Non-Conf | @ North Carolina | 7–32 | 4-2 | — |
| Nov 12 | Tourn | Journeymen Collegiate Classic | — | — | Freedom High School · Bethlehem, PA |
| Nov 17 | Non-Conf | vs. Virginia | 6–31 | 4-3 | — |
| Nov 17 | Non-Conf | @ Northern Colorado | 3–35 | 4-4 | — |
| Dec 2 | Non-Conf | vs. Chattanooga | 11–27 | 4-5 | — |
| Dec 2 | Non-Conf | @ Gardner-Webb | 15–17 | 4-6 | — |
| Dec 2 | Conf | @ Kent State | 25–15 | 5-6 | — |
| Dec 7 | Non-Conf | vs. Michigan State | 9–26 | 5-7 | — |
| Dec 10 | Non-Conf | @ Rutgers | 0–40 | 5-8 | — |
| Dec 17 | Non-Conf | @ Bucknell | 17–17 | 5-8-1 | — |
| Dec 17 | Conf | vs. Bloomsburg | 24–3 | 6-8-1 | — |
| Jan 7 | Conf | vs. SIUE | 9–25 | 6-9-1 | — |
| Jan 13 | Non-Conf | @ Binghamton | 3–31 | 6-10-1 | — |
| Jan 19 | Conf | @ Lock Haven | 23–12 | 7-10-1 | — |
| Jan 28 | Tourn | Lock Haven Mat Town College Open 2 | — | — | Thomas Field House · Lock Haven, PA |
| Feb 3 | Conf | @ Northern Illinois | 16–18 | 7-11-1 | — |
| Feb 8 | Conf | vs. Clarion | 18–16 | 8-11-1 | — |
| Feb 11 | Conf | @ Central Michigan | 6–28 | 8-12-1 | — |
| Feb 24 | Conf | @ Ohio | 28–9 | 9-12-1 | — |
| Feb 25 | Tourn | Patriots Last Chance Open | — | — | GMU Field House · Fairfax, VA |
| Mar 8 | MAC Champs | MAC Wrestling Championships | 85.55th | — | Memorial Athletic and Convocation Center · Kent, OH |
| Mar 21 | NCAA Champs | 2024 NCAA Championships | — | — | T-Mobile Center · Kansas City, MO |
