| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Jim Nance CUSE1st | DEC 2-1 | Larry Kristoff SIU-Carbondale |
| Medal Round | ||
| Joe James OKST3rd | DEC 4-3 | Merrell Solowin Toledo4th |
| Bob Spaly MICH5th | DEC 3-2 | John Illengwarth LEH6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Merrell Solowin Toledo | PIN 3:08 | Bob Spaly MICH |
| Joe James OKST | DEC 6-3 | John Illengwarth LEH |
| Semifinal | ||
| Larry Kristoff SIU-Carbondale | DEC 0-0 | Joe James OKST |
| Jim Nance CUSE | DEC 1-1 | Merrell Solowin Toledo |
| Consi 4 | ||
| John Illengwarth LEH | DEC 6-0 | Jerry Cabe UNC |
| Bob Spaly MICH | DEC 7-2 | Dick Zeyen Minnesota State University, Mankato |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Jim Nance CUSE | PIN 6:40 | Dick Zeyen Minnesota State University, Mankato |
| Larry Kristoff SIU-Carbondale | DEC 10-3 | John Illengwarth LEH |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Larry Kristoff SIU-Carbondale | PIN 7:14 | Jerry Cabe UNC |
| John Illengwarth LEH | PIN 3:41 | Bob Thiele KENT |
| Jim Nance CUSE | PIN 2:20 | Bob Spaly MICH |
| Homer McClure MSU | DEC 3-2 | Eddie McQuarters OKLA |