| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Johnny Harrell OKST1st | PIN 4:25 | John Sikich ILL2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Carmen Falcone KENT | DEC | |
| Adams OHIO |
| Carmen Falcone KENT | DEC | Larry Pickett YALE |
| John Sikich ILL | DEC | Carmen Falcone KENT |
| Raymond Hyde IND | DEC | Walter Wells LEH |
| Carmen Falcone KENT | DEC | Raymond Hyde IND |
| Semifinal | ||
| Johnny Harrell OKST | DEC | Larry Pickett YALE |
| John Sikich ILL | DEC | Raymond Hyde IND |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Johnny Harrell OKST | PIN 5:04 | Adams OHIO |
| John Sikich ILL | DEC | Walter Wells LEH |
| Raymond Hyde IND | DEC | A.A. Bergner NAVY |
| Larry Pickett YALE | DEC | Wilbur Nead IOWA |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Johnny Harrell OKST | DEC | Carmen Falcone KENT |
| A.A. Bergner NAVY | PIN 2:05 | F. Haddock MIT |
| Walter Wells LEH | PIN 2:25 | Forest Jordan MICH |
| Raymond Hyde IND | DEC | Richard Vaughan FM |
| Larry Pickett YALE | DEC | Leonard Cooke RU |
| Wilbur Nead IOWA | DEC | George Downes OSU |