| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Archie Deutschman ILL1st | DEC | Peter Culbertson MINN2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Bob Craig LEH | DEC | |
| Roger Isaacson UNI |
| Joe Roman IND | DEC | Bob Craig LEH |
| Joe Roman IND | DEC | Peter Culbertson MINN |
| Semifinal | ||
| Peter Culbertson MINN | DEC | C.F. Leigh NAVY |
| Archie Deutschman ILL | DEC | Joe Roman IND |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Peter Culbertson MINN | DEC | A. Barshay TEMPLE |
| Archie Deutschman ILL | DEC | Bob Craig LEH |
| Joe Roman IND | DEC | Leonard Pomeray KENT |
| C.F. Leigh NAVY | DEC | W.C. Sperry Illinois State |
| Round of 16 | ||
| W.C. Sperry Illinois State | PIN 2:12 | Bill Guttentag RU |
| Archie Deutschman ILL | DEC | Roger Isaacson UNI |
| Bob Craig LEH | DEC | V. Mowry Colorado State University |
| Peter Culbertson MINN | DEC | W.J. Knowles Springfield College |
| C.F. Leigh NAVY | DEC | William Luke NEB |
| Joe Roman IND | DEC | Eldon Jackson OKST |