| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Homer Barr PSU1st | DEC 7-1 | Gus LaSasso LEH2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Dave Whinfrey RU3rd | DEC 8-7 | Redmond Finney |
| Semifinal | ||
| Homer Barr PSU | DEC 7-1 | Redmond Finney PRIN |
| Gus LaSasso LEH | DEC 6-1 | Dave Whinfrey RU |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Homer Barr PSU | PIN 3:50 | Charles Keith HARV |
| Gus LaSasso LEH | PIN 4:02 | John Chernak BRWN |
| Redmond Finney PRIN | DEC 2-0 | James Hunt NAVY |
| Dave Whinfrey RU | DEC 5-0 | Jack Downey YALE |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Homer Barr PSU | PIN 1:35 | Austin Hepburn PENN |
| Charles Keith HARV | DEC 6-2 | Bruce Allen COR |
| Gus LaSasso LEH | PIN 2:11 | John Donahue TEMPLE |
| John Chernak BRWN | PIN 5:16 | Murray Winer CUSE |
| Dave Whinfrey RU | PIN 3:55 | John Clarkson UVA |
| Jack Downey YALE | — | Bennie Davis ARMY |
| Redmond Finney PRIN | DEC 5-0 | Bill Malone COLU |
| James Hunt NAVY | DEC 4-0 | Joel Rubin FM |