| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| George Gebhardt CUSE1st | DEC 3-2 | Mike Rubino PSU2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Brooks Naffziger YALE3rd | DEC 7-5 | |
| Russ Schelling FM4th |
| Semifinal | ||
| Mike Rubino PSU | PIN 7:00 | Brooks Naffziger YALE |
| George Gebhardt CUSE | DEC 7-1 | Russ Schelling FM |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| George Gebhardt CUSE | DEC 7-6 | David Jones NAVY |
| Russ Schelling FM | DEC 7-3 | Ray Vohden RU |
| Mike Rubino PSU | DEC 5-0 | Howard McLarin UVA |
| Brooks Naffziger YALE | DEC 7-5 | Herb Agocs PENN |
| Round of 16 | ||
| George Gebhardt CUSE | PIN 4:15 | Walt Bortko COR |
| David Jones NAVY | PIN 1:42 | Lou Scalzo ARMY |
| Ray Vohden RU | PIN 6:58 | Phil Donatelli LEH |
| Mike Rubino PSU | PIN 2:38 | George VanHassel COLU |
| Brooks Naffziger YALE | PIN 4:26 | Al Nipon TEMPLE |
| Herb Agocs PENN | PIN 5:29 | John Pentz PRIN |
| Russ Schelling FM | DEC 7-0 | Alex Marshall BRWN |
| Howard McLarin UVA | DEC 6-2 | Bob Claflin HARV |