| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Larry Pickett YALE1st | PIN | John Kerns PSU2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Bill Hitchcock LEH | PIN 5:18 | Bill Mozur CUSE |
| John Kerns PSU | PIN 3:20 | Bill Hitchcock LEH |
| Reginald Harrison COR | PIN 1:58 | Tom Rogstadt HARV |
| Reginald Harrison COR | DEC 3-0 | Carl Jacobs PRIN |
| Reginald Harrison COR | DEC 6-4 | Bill Hitchcock LEH |
| Bill Hitchcock LEH | DEC 7-4 | Art Emerson NAVY |
| Semifinal | ||
| John Kerns PSU | PIN 8:15 | Tom Rogstadt HARV |
| Larry Pickett YALE | PIN 4:37 | Bill Mozur CUSE |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Tom Rogstadt HARV | PIN 5:55 | Joe Hennessee ARMY |
| John Kerns PSU | — | Reginald Harrison COR |
| Larry Pickett YALE | PIN 8:16 | Art Emerson NAVY |
| Bill Mozur CUSE | PIN 6:32 | Harold Stenberg COLU |
| Pigtail | ||
| Reginald Harrison COR | — | Robert Wolf PENN |
| John Kerns PSU | PIN 2:59 | Carl Jacobs PRIN |
| Larry Pickett YALE | PIN 6:47 | Bill Hitchcock LEH |