| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Bob Eberle PRIN1st | — | James Laggan PENN2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Dick Nickerson COR | FORFEIT | James Redmon |
| Claire Hess PSU | FORFEIT | Dick Nickerson COR |
| Brooks Parker YALE | FORFEIT | Wendell Bevan ARMY |
| Brooks Parker YALE | PIN 1:42 | Bill O'Connell CUSE |
| James Laggan PENN | DEC 5-2 | Claire Hess PSU |
| Claire Hess PSU | DEC 6-5 | Brooks Parker YALE |
| Semifinal | ||
| Bob Eberle PRIN | — | Claire Hess PSU |
| James Laggan PENN | PIN 0:32 | Bill O'Connell CUSE |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Claire Hess PSU | — | Bill Norris COLU |
| James Laggan PENN | — | Brooks Parker YALE |
| Bill O'Connell CUSE | — | Robert Knox NAVY |
| Bob Eberle PRIN | DEFAULT | Dick Nickerson COR |
| Pigtail | ||
| Bob Eberle PRIN | PIN 4:15 | James Redmon HARV |
| James Laggan PENN | — | Wendell Bevan ARMY |
| Dick Nickerson COR | DEC 5-1 | Frank Bailey LEH |