| Nov 5 | vs. Stanford | Matt Sencenbaugh | Maj Dec 13-3 | 1-0 |
| Nov 12 | Michigan State Open Round of 32 | Greg Egbert | Pin W | 2-0 |
| Nov 12 | Michigan State Open Round of 16 | Brenan Lyon | Pin W | 3-0 |
| Nov 12 | Michigan State Open Quarterfinal | Robbie Bidlingmaier | Dec 10-3 | 4-0 |
| Nov 12 | Michigan State Open Semifinal | Joe Roth | Dec 6-1 | 5-0 |
| Nov 12 | Michigan State Open Final1st | Nick Smith | Pin W | 6-0 |
| Nov 20 | Keystone Classic Round of 16 | Mark Maestrey | Maj Dec 13-0 | 7-0 |
| Nov 20 | Keystone Classic Quarterfinal | Ryan Dowd | Pin 6:47 | 8-0 |
| Nov 20 | Keystone Classic Semifinal | Joe Barbato | Pin 1:46 | 9-0 |
| Nov 20 | Keystone Classic Final1st | Garrett Frey | Dec 8-3 | 10-0 |
| Dec 11 | vs. Indianapolis | Josh Kieffer | Pin 5:30 | 11-0 |
| Dec 11 | SIUE vs Indianapolis | — | Forfeit W | 12-0 |
| Dec 16 | vs. North Central | Nathan Fitzenreider | Dec 3-0 | 13-0 |
| Dec 29 | Midlands Championships Round of 32 | Adam Wyeth | Pin 3:48 | 14-0 |
| Dec 29 | Midlands Championships Round of 16 | Vinny Dellafave | Forfeit W | 15-0 |
| Dec 29 | Midlands Championships Quarterfinal | Trent Sprenkle | Dec 7-0 | 16-0 |
| Dec 29 | Midlands Championships Semifinal | Jarrod Garnett | Dec 4-3 | 16-1 |
| Dec 29 | Midlands Championships 3rd Place4th | Jesse Delgado | Pin 3:44 | 16-2 |
| Jan 6 | vs. Michigan | Grant Pizzo | Pin 3:36 | 17-2 |
| Jan 8 | @ Wisconsin | Austin Hietpas | Maj Dec 14-1 | 18-2 |
| Jan 13 | vs. Penn State | Nico Megaludis | Dec 7-3 | 18-3 |
| Jan 15 | @ Iowa | Matt McDonough | Maj Dec 18-4 | 18-4 |
| Jan 20 | vs. Michigan State | Eric Olanowski | Pin 3:29 | 19-4 |
| Jan 27 | @ Illinois | Jesse Delgado | Dec 13-7 | 20-4 |
| Jan 29 | @ Purdue | Camden Eppert | Dec 6-0 | 21-4 |
| Feb 3 | @ Northern Illinois | Nick Smith | Dec 3-0 | 22-4 |
| Feb 11 | @ Campbell | Grabiel Soto | Pin 3:53 | 23-4 |
| Feb 17 | vs. Indiana | Zachary Zimmer | Dec 9-4 | 24-4 |
| Mar 3 | Big Ten Championships Round of 16 | Zachary Zimmer | Pin 2:32 | 25-4 |
| Mar 3 | Big Ten Championships Quarterfinal | Jesse Delgado | Dec 6-2 | 25-5 |
| Mar 3 | Big Ten Championships Consi 8 #2 | Grant Pizzo | Dec 5-0 | 26-5 |
| Mar 3 | Big Ten Championships Consi 4 | Austin Hietpas | Maj Dec 12-0 | 27-5 |
| Mar 3 | Big Ten Championships Consi Semi | Nico Megaludis | Pin 7:35 | 28-5 |
| Mar 3 | Big Ten Championships 3rd Place4th | Jesse Delgado | Dec 6-1 | 28-6 |
| Mar 15 | 2012 NCAA Championships Round of 32 | Garrett Frey | Pin W | 29-6 |
| Mar 15 | 2012 NCAA Championships Round of 16 | Ryan Mango | Maj Dec 15-6 | 29-7 |
| Mar 15 | 2012 NCAA Championships Consi 16 #2 | Pat Rollins | Dec 6-4 | 29-8 |
| Season Total | 19 Bonus | 29-8 |
