| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Darrion Caldwell NCST | PIN 0:32 | Jeremy Depoy KENT |
| Brandon Bucher GMU | PIN 5:30 | Mike Bell DUKE |
| Andrew Swank Boston University | DEC 3-2 | Richard Dehnz Unattached |
| DJ Meagher COR | DEC 4-0 | PJ Gillespie HOF |
| Nick Stabile UNC | DEC 7-0 | Calvin Miller CSUB |
| Scott Heckman East Stroudsburg University | DEFAULT | Louis Johnson Unattached |
| Peter Ferrara UVA | DEC 12-11 | Matt Fittery LHU |
| Torsten Gillespie EDIN | DEC 8-2 | Adam Broda VT |
| Mike Roberts Boston University | PIN 2:41 | Frankie Gayeski LIB |
| Matt Kaylor BING | DEC 5-2 | Thomas Windom KENT |
| Ben Wilmore UNCG | PIN 4:12 | William Powell APP |
| Pete Yates VT | DEC 6-0 | Thomas Knapp GWU |
| Kaylen Baxter ODU | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Daniel Kolodzik PRIN |
| Donnie Vinson Unattached | DEC 8-4 | Clint Sponseller KENT |
| Nick Murray Unattached | TF 15-0 | Alex Lauffenburger BLOOM |
| Bryce Saddoris NAVY | MAJ DEC 15-4 | Savva Kostis APP |