| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Paul Donahoe EDIN | PIN 2:39 | Ryan Dowd Boston University |
| Cortney Roberts GWU | DEC 11-6 | Jeremiah Biddle BLOOM |
| Frank Lomas CSUB | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Richard Alarcon CIT |
| Brock LiVorio VT | PIN 1:15 | Joe Pantaleo LIB |
| Nicholas Bedelyon KENT | PIN 3:42 | Ben Altman DAV |
| Steve Bonanno HOF | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Nick Hyatt LHU |
| Eric Morrill Unattached | MAJ DEC 12-1 | Wes Heavener CAMP |
| Ian Moser BLOOM | DEC 10-6 | Gabe Ramos Unattached |
| Brandon Zoetewey CSUB | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Nick Shields UNC |
| Matthew Snyder Unattached | PIN 2:49 | Michael Moreno NCST |
| C.J. Gittens CAMP | DEC 5-1 | Stephen Sabreen FM |
| Kyle Fluke EDIN | PIN 5:18 | Brian Wright GMU |
| Ross Gitomer UVA | DEC 4-3 | Troy Opfer KENT |
| Allan Stein NAVY | DEC 13-10 | Mitchell Johnson UNCG |
| Evan Kolb Unattached | PIN 2:40 | Robert Benitez PRIN |
| Fred Santaite Boston University | PIN 1:33 | Andrew Sifakis APP |