| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi Pigtail | ||
| Jeremiah Fennell CAMP | PIN 4:02 | Mike Patterson BING |
| John Buck CIT | DEC 4-2 | Derrick Callaway APP |
| Leon Barrow VMI | DEC 4-1 | Scott Smith UVA |
| Jason Manross COR | PIN 1:57 | Nick Roehrick GWU |
| Jack Danilkowicz UVA | DEC 8-2 | Joe Ellwood OHIO |
| Scott Buhman VMI | DEC 11-4 | Jerry Afari MD |
| Ryan Kittrick GMU | DEC 6-2 | Markley Morrison UNCG |
| Sean Connole Unattached | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Phillip Doerner STAN |
| John Price MD | PIN 3:37 | David Morgan CSUB |
| Daniel Goetter UNC | MAJ DEC 14-4 | Marcus Adelman OHIO |
| Willie Leonard KENT | PIN 6:52 | Ryan Tomei PITT |
| Ryan Bergman CSUB | PIN 4:55 | Mike Cook LHU |
| Matt Pellar ODU | PIN 1:10 | Erik Olson VMI |
| Ryan Hsu UNCG | DEC 6-3 | Matt Rosner East Stroudsburg University |
| Eric Parker CSUB | PIN 3:29 | Mike Tunick DUKE |