| Round of 16 |
| James Benjamin BUFF | PIN | Jared Hallberg Jamestown Community College |
| Shane Bartrum Ithaca College | DEC 11-5 | Eddie McBride Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Chris Ramirez Ithaca College | PIN | Mike Hughes HOF |
| Tyler Deuel BING | PIN | El Shadai VanHoesen Niagara County Community College |
| Lance Moore SUNY-Cortland | DEC 8-3 | Patryk Kopczynski Hunter College |
| Jim Donner Niagara County Community College | DEC 2-1 | Cole Tristram SUNY Brockport |
| Stephen Snyder ARMY | PIN | Branden Jones SUNY-Oswego |
| Andy Scopino SUNY-Cortland | PIN | Ob Anyichie Westchester Community College |
| Trevor Smith ARMY | MAJ DEC 13-3 | Corey Quintana SUNY Brockport |
| Conor Sweeney COLU | DEC 9-4 | Dan Fazzino Westchester Community College |
| Mike Silvis BUFF | DEC 3-2 | Joseph Sprung Ithaca College |
| Jacob Aiken-Phillips COR | PIN | Richard Dracup Ithaca College |
| Wyatt Baker COLU | PIN | Lautaro Epstein Stony Brook Wrestling Club |
| Brian Walker US Merchant Marine Academy | PIN | Shaborn Fenner Nassau Community College |
| George Famutimi COR | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Robert Tkach Stony Brook Wrestling Club |
