| Round of 16 |
| Daniel Graff Oneonta State | DEC 5-1 | Dariyan Riley Nassau Community College |
| Lou Puca SUNY-Cortland | PIN | Alexander Smith ARMY |
| Eric Fajardo COLU | MAJ DEC 15-5 | Josh Miller US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Frank Affronti HOF | DEC 4-2 | Brian Harvey ARMY |
| Carlos Toribio Ithaca College | MAJ DEC 16-5 | Javon Tolliver Jamestown Community College |
| Shane Hughes COLU | DEC 6-3 | Tyler Rill BUFF |
| Owen Scott COR | DEC 4-0 | Victor Pozsonyi HOF |
| Roy Daniels SUNY Brockport | PIN | Patrick Sause SUNY Sullivan |
| Patrick Rooney US Merchant Marine Academy | PIN | Colin Ferral SUNY Cortland Wrestling Club |
| Peter Hailer SUNY Brockport | DEC 6-4 | Liam Bass Oneonta State |
| Josh Reed SUNY-Cortland | PIN | Nicholas Ranieri SUNY Cortland Wrestling Club |
| George Pickett COR | PIN | James Danko Westchester Community College |
| Jarred Lux BUFF | DEC 5-3 | Jack McKeever BING |
| Austin Weigel BUFF | DEC 4-3 | Will Bonagura Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute |
| Andrew Psomas COLU | DEC 5-1 | Shane Currey Niagara County Community College |
| Jesse Shanaman COR | PIN | Andrew Keane US Merchant Marine Academy |
