| Consi 16 #2 |
| Tim McCann Hunter College | PIN | Patrick DeFoe Alfred State College |
| Marcus Popp Niagara County Community College | DEC 5-0 | Julian Arroyo Nassau Community College |
| Noah Phillips SUNY-Oswego | PIN | Vincent Turano Nassau Community College |
| Jake Sepor Rochester Institute of Technology | DEC 5-4 | Wonsik Kim Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Charles Garcia Oneonta State | PIN | Kevin Jiminez Westchester Community College |
| Eli Bienstock COR | TF 18-3 | Alex Nicosia US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Nicholas Matthews NYU | PIN | Mike Figueroa Westchester Community College |
| Kyle Vershay SUNY-Oswego | PIN | Alain Alisca Stony Brook Wrestling Club |
| Tyler Edwards Ithaca College | PIN | Marcus Bernardino USMA Prep School |
| Griffin Higginbothan Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | DEC 6-5 | Sean Romanski SUNY Brockport |
| Todd Williams Nassau Community College | PIN | William Gregory NYU |
