| Bill Harlow OKST2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Jerry Swope LHU3rd | DEC 3-2 | Marshall Dauberman MD4th |
| Gerry Franzen NAVY5th | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Bob Hannah YALE6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Marshall Dauberman MD | DEC 2-2 | Bob Hannah YALE |
| Jerry Swope LHU | DEC 6-5 | Gerry Franzen NAVY |
| Semifinal | ||
| Bill Harlow OKST | DEC 5-2 | Gerry Franzen NAVY |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Jerry Swope LHU | PIN 3:30 | Roy Sisler WVU |
| Bob Hannah YALE | DEC 3-2 | Art Oraschin Lycoming |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Dean Lahr Colorado College | PIN 7:32 | Bob Hannah YALE |
| Gerry Franzen NAVY | DEC 5-1 | George Reid PUR |
| Bill Harlow OKST | DEC 6-2 | Jerry Swope LHU |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Gerry Franzen NAVY | PIN 5:09 | Bob Ramstad MINN |
| Bill Harlow OKST | PIN 0:56 | Roy Sisler WVU |
| Marshall Dauberman MD | DEC 5-4 | Richard Isel IND |
| Bob Hannah YALE | DEFAULT | Brekke Johnson WIS |
| George Reid PUR | DEC 4-3 | Jim Grover ISU |
| Jerry Swope LHU | DEC 8-3 | Joe Cerra Springfield College |
| Dean Lahr Colorado College | DEC 8-1 | Art Oraschin Lycoming |
| Ken Barr PITT | DEC 4-2 | Dick Ernst NW |
| Pigtail | ||
| Roy Sisler WVU | PIN 7:48 | Joe Arcure MICH |
| Brekke Johnson WIS | DEC 7-2 | Bob Shearer KENT |
| Richard Isel IND | DEC 3-1 | Mike Wittenberg COR |
| Art Oraschin Lycoming | DEC 3-2 | Bruce Alexander Toledo |
| Jim Grover ISU | DEC 9-8 | Emerson Bales MSU |