| PIN 7:57 |
| Don Namroz Ball State |
| Autry Ehler Portland State University | PIN 3:40 | Jim Lightner United States Coast Guard Academy |
| Ron Pifer PSU | PIN 4:21 | Harry Schlieff MINN |
| Bob Davis West Chester | DEC 5-0 | Bill Daniels VMI |
| Frank Hankin Utah | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Leon Gridley SUNY-Oswego |
| Art Kraft NW | DEC 9-3 | Gerry Rinker RU |
| Bob Marshall PUR | DEC 2-0 | Bob Johnson OKST |
| Sid Terry OKLA | DEC 5-2 | Ray Guzak NIU |
| Ron Meleney ISU | DEC 4-0 | Bob Rohm BLOOM |
| Gene Kerin MD | DEC 9-4 | Bob Dake Bowling Green |
| Walter Parker Cornell College | DEC 3-3 | Roger Tavenner MSU |
| Fritz Fivian ORST | DEC 4-0 | Dick Zoyhofski Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Joe Mullins IOWA | DEC 4-2 | Monte Peterson Minnesota State |
| Thad Turner LEH | DEC 8-2 | Francis Flesner SDSU |