| PIN 5:11 |
| Bob Gaskill Colorado State University |
| Art Kraft NW | DEC 5-2 | Frank Hankin Utah |
| Ellie Watkins ISU | DEC 8-2 | John Kreamer LHU |
| Fritz Fivian ORST | DEC 5-0 | Gerald Ray UNI |
| Bob Rohm BLOOM | DEC 6-2 | Ron Fretheim Luther College |
| Harry Schlieff MINN | DEC 2-1 | Dave Abraham Colorado College |
| Herman Ayres SIU-Carbondale | DEC 4-3 | Francis Flesner SDSU |
| Dick Beattie OKST | DEC 4-1 | Jim Gass Cornell College |
| Tom Gabbard ILL | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Buddy Snyder WYO |
| Al Gibbons Carleton | DEC 7-4 | Brad Tate Adams State |
| Tom Robinson PUR | DEC 7-6 | Dick Besnier MD |