| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Tom Alberts PITT1st | ||
| DEC 8-5 |
| Ralph Schneider Waynesburg University2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Rex Edgar OKLA3rd | DEC 4-1 | Roy Minter Minnesota State4th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Roy Minter Minnesota State | DEC 6-0 | Frank Powell ISU |
| Rex Edgar OKLA | DEC 8-3 | Ken Kraft NW |
| Semifinal | ||
| Tom Alberts PITT | DEC 2-0 | Ken Kraft NW |
| Ralph Schneider Waynesburg University | DEC 3-1 | Frank Powell ISU |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Rex Edgar OKLA | — | Frank Gutierrez Muhlenberg |
| Roy Minter Minnesota State | DEC 6-2 | Bob Foster HARV |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Ken Kraft NW | DEC | Ray McGuire UNCO |
| Frank Powell ISU | DEC 7-2 | Jack Marchello MICH |
| Ralph Schneider Waynesburg University | DEC 5-3 | Roy Minter Minnesota State |
| Tom Alberts PITT | DEC 8-6 | Rex Edgar OKLA |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Tom Alberts PITT | PIN 4:22 | Frank Gutierrez Muhlenberg |
| Frank Powell ISU | DEC 7-0 | Dave Atkinson UNC |
| Roy Minter Minnesota State | DEC 3-1 | Jim Ferguson MSU |
| Rex Edgar OKLA | DEC 10-4 | Ed Rath Colorado State University |
| Jack Marchello MICH | DEC 9-5 | Ken Koenig KENT |
| Ralph Schneider Waynesburg University | DEC 7-2 | Jim Craig IOWA |
| Ray McGuire UNCO | DEC 4-3 | Duane Murty OKST |
| Ken Kraft NW | DEC 3-2 | Neal Lesher RU |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Jack Marchello MICH | PIN 5:20 | Walter Kohler Hiram College |
| Ken Koenig KENT | DEC 3-1 | John Anderson Cornell College |
| Neal Lesher RU | PIN 5:43 | Tom Murphy UNI |
| Roy Minter Minnesota State | DEC 5-2 | Dick Dean MD |
| Ray McGuire UNCO | DEC 3-0 | John Ellwood LHU |
| Jim Craig IOWA | DEC 5-0 | John Wright VT |
| Ken Kraft NW | DEC 4-3 | Steve Smethurst COR |
| Jim Ferguson MSU | DEC 4-0 | George Gray PSU |
| Rex Edgar OKLA | DEC 6-1 | Harold Brownstein ILL |
| Ed Rath Colorado State University | DEC 3-0 | Bernard Stolls CCNY |
| Ralph Schneider Waynesburg University | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Bob Foster HARV |
| Duane Murty OKST | DEC 8-5 | Bob Koehen MINN |