| Harmon Leslie OKST2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Dick Mueller MINN3rd | DEC 3-0 | Leonard Shelton OKLA4th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Leonard Shelton OKLA | DEC 4-1 | Don Stroud MSU |
| Dick Mueller MINN | DEC 2-0 | Sid Nodland PSU |
| Semifinal | ||
| Harmon Leslie OKST | DEC 7-5 | Dick Mueller MINN |
| Ed Peery PITT | DEC 5-1 | Don Stroud MSU |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Sid Nodland PSU | — | Charles Green Cornell College |
| Leonard Shelton OKLA | DEC 2-0 | Ray Haney MD |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Harmon Leslie OKST | DEC 8-7 | Sid Nodland PSU |
| Dick Mueller MINN | DEC 3-0 | Larry Moser IOWA |
| Don Stroud MSU | DEC 3-1 | Herb Karcher WYO |
| Ed Peery PITT | DEC 6-0 | Leonard Shelton OKLA |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Leonard Shelton OKLA | PIN 8:14 | Tom Westfall WVU |
| Harmon Leslie OKST | PIN 7:48 | Charles Green Cornell College |
| Herb Karcher WYO | DEC 5-1 | Joel Neuschwander ORST |
| Ed Peery PITT | DEC 4-0 | Ray Haney MD |
| Dick Mueller MINN | DEC 5-0 | Don Corrigan UNI |
| Larry Moser IOWA | DEC 8-3 | George Creason CUSE |
| Sid Nodland PSU | DEC 4-3 | Dave Harty ISU |
| Don Stroud MSU | DEC 3-2 | Jim Miller Kansas State |
| Pigtail | ||
| Dick Mueller MINN | PIN 5:00 | Joe Ornowski OHIO |
| Ray Haney MD | MAJ DEC 8-0 | George Munnich Kings Point |