| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Bill Weick | ||
| DEC 6-4 |
| Mike Rodriguez MICH2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Ed DeWitt PITT3rd | DEC 1-0 | Ed Rooney CUSE4th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Ed Rooney CUSE | DEC 5-2 | Ron Teuber Colorado College |
| Ed DeWitt PITT | DEC 7-4 | Delbert Lockwood Colorado State University |
| Semifinal | ||
| Bill Weick UNI | DEC | Ed DeWitt PITT |
| Mike Rodriguez MICH | DEC 13-8 | Ed Rooney CUSE |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Ron Teuber Colorado College | DEC | Peter Damone HOF |
| Delbert Lockwood Colorado State University | DEC 4-1 | Vincent Kelly Loyola MD |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Ron Teuber Colorado College | DEC 3-0 | Neal Lesher RU |
| Vincent Kelly Loyola MD | FORFEIT | Norman Balot CCNY |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Ed DeWitt PITT | DEC | John Winder IOWA |
| Mike Rodriguez MICH | PIN 7:00 | Peter Damone HOF |
| Bill Weick UNI | DEC 4-1 | Delbert Lockwood Colorado State University |
| Ed Rooney CUSE | DEC 11-4 | Bill Smoot OKST |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Ed DeWitt PITT | PIN 8:25 | Joe Humphreys PSU |
| John Winder IOWA | PIN 5:47 | Dale Ward ARMY |
| Delbert Lockwood Colorado State University | PIN 4:43 | Roger Taylor LEH |
| Ed Rooney CUSE | PIN 1:06 | Luther Seeber WIS |
| Mike Rodriguez MICH | PIN 2:34 | Ron Teuber Colorado College |
| Bill Weick UNI | DEC 6-0 | Vincent Kelly Loyola MD |
| Bill Smoot OKST | DEC 10-5 | Bill Bock Springfield College |
| Peter Damone HOF | DEC 6-2 | Bob Bormuth WYO |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Ed DeWitt PITT | PIN 3:33 | Jerry Schroeder Minnesota State |
| Dale Ward ARMY | PIN 8:17 | George McGee UNC |
| Ed Rooney CUSE | PIN 2:40 | Jerry Bross OKLA |
| Luther Seeber WIS | PIN 5:45 | Harry Scott COLU |
| Peter Damone HOF | PIN 4:34 | Frank Kastor ILL |
| John Winder IOWA | MAJ DEC 15-4 | Don Chatwick Baldwin Wallace University |
| Bill Weick UNI | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Norman Balot CCNY |
| Vincent Kelly Loyola MD | DEC 3-1 | Ned Tudi COR |
| Bob Bormuth WYO | DEC 5-0 | Gerry Chadwick DUKE |
| Delbert Lockwood Colorado State University | DEC 9-3 | Don Dykhoff SDSU |
| Roger Taylor LEH | DEC 5-2 | Bill Fisher MVILLE |
| Bill Smoot OKST | DEC 9-6 | Dick Lennox MSU |
| Bill Bock Springfield College | DEC 11-9 | Sam Downey Auburn |
| Mike Rodriguez MICH | MAJ DEC 14-4 | Neal Lesher RU |