| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Eddie Eichelberger | ||
| PIN 6:43 |
| Lloyd Corwin Cornell College2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Doug Blubaugh OKST3rd | DEC 4-1 | George Mulligan RU4th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| George Mulligan RU | PIN 5:24 | John O'Neil Wheaton |
| Doug Blubaugh OKST | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Bud Weick PUR |
| Semifinal | ||
| Eddie Eichelberger LEH | DEC 10-5 | George Mulligan RU |
| Lloyd Corwin Cornell College | DEC 3-1 | Bud Weick PUR |
| Consi 4 | ||
| John O'Neil Wheaton | DEC 3-0 | Bob Cook PITT |
| Doug Blubaugh OKST | DEC 3-0 | Ed Jackson ILL |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| John O'Neil Wheaton | FORFEIT | Don Bills Ithaca College |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Eddie Eichelberger LEH | PIN 2:39 | Bob Cook PITT |
| George Mulligan RU | DEC 8-4 | Stan Wintermote WYO |
| Lloyd Corwin Cornell College | DEC 5-3 | Doug Blubaugh OKST |
| Bud Weick PUR | DEC 9-5 | Lee Young OKLA |
| Round of 16 | ||
| George Mulligan RU | DEC | Don Haney MICH |
| Eddie Eichelberger LEH | PIN 6:42 | Don Bills Ithaca College |
| Lee Young OKLA | PIN 5:34 | Ralph Hutchinson Lafayette |
| Stan Wintermote WYO | DEC 4-0 | Dave Adams PSU |
| Bud Weick PUR | DEC 6-2 | Richard Simmons TEMPLE |
| Doug Blubaugh OKST | DEC 5-2 | Roland Alexander Kansas State |
| Bob Cook PITT | DEC 6-3 | Ray Farris Kings Point |
| Lloyd Corwin Cornell College | DEC 7-1 | Ed Jackson ILL |
| Pigtail | ||
| Eddie Eichelberger LEH | PIN 5:26 | John O'Neil Wheaton |
| Doug Blubaugh OKST | DEC 4-1 | Roger Judd COR |