| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Walter Romanowski Cornell College1st | DEC 5-4 | Hal Moore OKST2nd |
| Gene Lybbert UNI3rd | DEC 3-2 | Jack Blubaugh OKLA4th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Jack Blubaugh OKLA | FORFEIT | George Lewis Waynesburg University |
| Gene Lybbert UNI | DEC 7-1 | Richard Pickard ILL |
| Semifinal | ||
| Walter Romanowski Cornell College | DEC | George Lewis Waynesburg University |
| Hal Moore OKST | DEC 8-3 | Gene Lybbert UNI |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Jack Blubaugh OKLA | PIN 3:30 | George Mills HOF |
| Richard Pickard ILL | DEC 10-3 | David Kikuchi California-Berkeley |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| George Lewis Waynesburg University | DEC 10-4 | Phil Duggan IOWA |
| Walter Romanowski Cornell College | DEC 8-7 | Jack Blubaugh OKLA |
| Hal Moore OKST | DEC 7-2 | Richard Pickard ILL |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Hal Moore OKST | DEC 8-4 | David Kikuchi California-Berkeley |
| Richard Pickard ILL | DEC | Dean Harbold PSU |
| Gene Lybbert UNI | DEC 10-5 | John Heacock LHU |
| George Lewis Waynesburg University | DEC 7-1 | Bill Donecho Springfield College |
| Phil Duggan IOWA | DEC 8-7 | Bob Gerbino CUSE |
| Jack Blubaugh OKLA | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Harold Miller PITT |
| Walter Romanowski Cornell College | DEC 7-0 | George Mills HOF |