| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Bill Nelson UNI | PIN 4:28 | Dale Federer WYO |
| Don Mullison | ||
| PIN 4:00 |
| Bob Dwyer ILL |
| James LaRock Ithaca College | PIN 2:13 | Jim Dowe POLY |
| Pat Sullivan MSU | PIN 4:01 | Charles Mancuso University of Nebraska Omaha |
| Rodger Snook Cornell College | PIN 4:42 | Glenn McCarty Utah State |
| Ken Hunte CUSE | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Hugh Evans Colorado School of Mines |
| Peter Wilson Wheaton | DEC 6-1 | Al Mott Colorado College |
| Phil Smith Auburn | DEC 10-6 | Leon Tedder OKST |