| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Garnett Inman IND1st | DEC | Al Crawford APP2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| James Taylor Cornell College | — | Dick Brenneman |
| Leon Reynard Kansas State | PIN 10:30 | James Taylor Cornell College |
| Joe Aschauer KENT | PIN 11:07 | Stanley Koloski St. Lawrence |
| Joe Aschauer KENT | FORFEIT | Al Crawford APP |
| Leon Reynard Kansas State | DEC | Joe Aschauer KENT |
| Garnett Inman IND | DEC | Leon Reynard Kansas State |
| Semifinal | ||
| Don Nichols MICH | DEC | James Taylor Cornell College |
| Garnett Inman IND | DEC | Joe Aschauer KENT |
| Al Crawford APP | DEC | Leb Wizitzer CCNY |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| William Hoffman RU | — | Lloyd Black TEMPLE |
| Al Crawford APP | DEC | Paul Goverdare ILL |
| Don Nichols MICH | DEC | Dick Brenneman LEH |
| Leb Wizitzer CCNY | DEC | Denton Caves Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Garnett Inman IND | DEC | Stanley Koloski St. Lawrence |