| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Harold Byrd OKLA1st | DEC | Dale Hanson MINN2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| John Hess Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | |
| Phillip Geib FM |
| John Hess Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Ben Wilson IND |
| Bob Kitt OKST | DEC | Ed Dillon ILL |
| Bob Kitt OKST | DEC | John Hess Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Dale Hanson MINN | DEC | John Hess Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Ed Dillon ILL | DEC | Robert McArdle WVU |
| Semifinal | ||
| Dale Hanson MINN | PIN 7:50 | Bob Kitt OKST |
| Harold Byrd OKLA | DEC | Ben Wilson IND |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Harold Byrd OKLA | DEC | John Hess Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Ben Wilson IND | DEC | Milton Conzett University of Dubuque |
| Dale Hanson MINN | DEC | Ed Dillon ILL |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Dale Hanson MINN | PIN 7:45 | Robert McArdle WVU |
| Ed Dillon ILL | PIN 8:35 | Lindo Nangeroni RU |
| Ben Wilson IND | PIN 6:52 | Milt Gaskill APP |
| Milton Conzett University of Dubuque | PIN 7:07 | Harold Northrup WYO |
| Harold Byrd OKLA | DEC | Phillip Geib FM |
| John Hess Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Clarence Shapiro CCNY |
| Peter Bernardino TEMPLE | DEC | Robert Biren Cornell College |