| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consolation | ||
| Calvin Mehlhorn OKST | PIN 8:00 | Charles Parks APP |
| Charles Parks APP | DEC | Bill Davidson OHIO |
| Calvin Mehlhorn | ||
| DEC |
| Delbert Jensen UNI |
| Semifinal | ||
| Robert Antonacci IND | PIN 5:18 | Charles Parks APP |
| Delbert Jensen UNI | DEC | Farland Fansher Kansas State |
| Calvin Mehlhorn OKST | DEC | Robert Johnson Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Frank Burgess FM | PIN 6:25 | Ray Tyson WVU |
| Delbert Jensen UNI | PIN 4:57 | John Cooper St. Lawrence |
| Calvin Mehlhorn OKST | DEC | Robert Lungwitz University of Dubuque |
| Casey Fredericks PUR | DEC | George Young OKLA |
| Robert Antonacci IND | FORFEIT | Bill Davidson OHIO |
| Charles Parks APP | DEC | Kim Hill ILL |
| Robert Johnson Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Carl King PSU |
| Farland Fansher Kansas State | DEC | Merl Smith WYO |
| Pigtail | ||
| Merl Smith WYO | DEC | Robert Levin CCNY |