| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Joe McDaniel OKST1st | DEC | Dale Hanson MINN2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Willard Duffy IND | DEC | Dale Hanson MINN |
| Davis Natvig UNI | DEC | Hirschtritt CCNY |
| Davis Natvig UNI | DEC | Dale Hanson MINN |
| Dale Hanson MINN | DEC | Carl King PSU |
| Semifinal | ||
| Joe McDaniel OKST | PIN 2:50 | Carl King PSU |
| Davis Natvig UNI | PIN 8:22 | Bench Utah |
| Willard Duffy IND | — | Hirschtritt CCNY |
| Dale Hanson MINN | DEC | Hennis Lawley Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Davis Natvig UNI | PIN 3:15 | Franc Burnett LEH |
| Bench Utah | — | Ken Stewart ISU |
| Carl King PSU | DEC | George Benz St. Lawrence |
| Hennis Lawley Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | P. Satterfield WVU |
| Dale Hanson MINN | DEC | Argyros Alfred |