| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Wayne Martin OKLA1st | DEC | Jack McIlvoy ILL2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Louis Tomlinson | ||
| DEC |
| Elmer Nazworthy OKST |
| Bill Glass WVU | DEFAULT | Earl Yocum East Stroudsburg University |
| Louis Tomlinson University of Central Oklahoma | FORFEIT | Bill Glass WVU |
| Louis Tomlinson University of Central Oklahoma | DEC | Jack McIlvoy ILL |
| Semifinal | ||
| Wayne Martin OKLA | DEC | Elmer Nazworthy OKST |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Wayne Martin OKLA | PIN 3:37 | Louis Tomlinson University of Central Oklahoma |
| Walter Crockett LEH | DEC | Ed Werner FM |
| Elmer Nazworthy OKST | DEC | Bill Cramer PSU |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Walter Crockett LEH | PIN 5:14 | Jervis Webb MIT |
| Wayne Martin OKLA | PIN 6:22 | Earl Yocum East Stroudsburg University |
| Elmer Nazworthy OKST | PIN 5:06 | Rene Blanc-Roos Haverford |
| Bill Cramer PSU | PIN 6:25 | Charles Demetriades TEMPLE |
| Ed Werner FM | DEC | Frank Sayer St. Lawrence |
| Louis Tomlinson University of Central Oklahoma | DEC | Walter Jacob MSU |
| Karl Kitt Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Glenn Shively Washington & Lee |
| Pigtail | ||
| Karl Kitt Southwestern Oklahoma | PIN 8:46 | Byron Guernsey IOWA |
| Wayne Martin OKLA | PIN 8:44 | Bill Glass WVU |
| Glenn Shively Washington & Lee | DEC | Gene Howe Kansas State |
| Jack McIlvoy ILL | DEFAULT | Post Northeastern State |
| Louis Tomlinson University of Central Oklahoma | DEC | Fred Scott KENT |
| Walter Jacob MSU | DEC | Dick Hingston Tufts |