| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Vernon Sisney OKLA1st | DEC | Ralph Rasor OKST2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Robert Larson IOWA | PIN 3:59 | |
| Roland Skinner Haverford |
| Ralph Rasor OKST | DEC | George Hanks Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Harold Slate Tufts | DEC | Archie Witt VMI |
| George Hanks Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Harold Slate Tufts |
| George Hanks Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Robert Larson IOWA |
| Harold Slate Tufts | DEC | Ken Carpenter ILL |
| Semifinal | ||
| Ralph Rasor OKST | PIN 9:03 | Ken Carpenter ILL |
| Vernon Sisney OKLA | DEC | George Hanks Southwestern Oklahoma |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Ken Carpenter ILL | PIN 3:43 | Keith Bueghly UNI |
| Vernon Sisney OKLA | DEC | Robert Larson IOWA |
| George Hanks Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Frank Horner FM |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Ken Carpenter ILL | PIN 7:13 | Jack Light PSU |
| Ralph Rasor OKST | DEC | Harold Slate Tufts |
| Vernon Sisney OKLA | DEC | Roland Skinner Haverford |
| Robert Larson IOWA | DEC | William Conrad LEH |
| Frank Horner FM | DEC | Paul Curtis TEMPLE |
| George Hanks Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Art Frye ARMY |
| Keith Bueghly UNI | DEC | Lewis Morgan Rochester Institute of Technology |