| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consolation | ||
| Pete Pakutinsky ILL | DEC | Joe Rivers Haverford |
| Jack Gott Southwestern Oklahoma | DEC | Thomas McCarthy IND |
| Pete Pakutinsky | ||
| DEC |
| Charles Smith LEH |
| Ray Cheney UNI | DEC | Emmett Zabriskie St. Lawrence |
| Thomas McCarthy IND | DEC | Ray Cheney UNI |
| Pete Pakutinsky ILL | DEFAULT | Thomas McCarthy IND |