| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Patrick Devine IND1st | PIN 7:06 | Pat Johnson HARV2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Roy Phillips | ||
| PIN 4:56 |
| Pat Johnson HARV |
| Roy Phillips FM | DEC | Adolph Paris Ursinus College |
| Roy Phillips FM | DEC | Kenneth Becker Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Semifinal | ||
| Pat Johnson HARV | DEC | John Brindley UNI |
| Patrick Devine IND | DEC | Adolph Paris Ursinus College |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Pat Johnson HARV | DEC | Thomas McCray ARMY |
| Adolph Paris Ursinus College | PIN 1:47 | Charles Glatzer KENT |
| Patrick Devine IND | DEC | Kenneth Becker Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Thomas McCray ARMY | PIN 5:56 | Harry Blank Washington & Jefferson |
| Pat Johnson HARV | DEC | Arch Keller OHIO |
| Charles Glatzer KENT | PIN 5:47 | Bill Fismer LEH |
| Adolph Paris Ursinus College | DEC | Peter Kalajian COLU |
| Kenneth Becker Rochester Institute of Technology | PIN 3:38 | Sam Barnes OKST |
| Patrick Devine IND | DEC | Roy Phillips FM |
| John Brindley UNI | DEC | Henry Oshry MIT |
| Pigtail | ||
| Arch Keller OHIO | PIN | Robert Trout Lafayette |