| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Robert Hess ISU1st | DEC | Joe Sintic OHIO2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Barney Cosneck ILL | — | Ellis Bashara OKLA |
| Barney Cosneck | ||
| — |
| Joe Sintic OHIO |
| LeRoy McGuirk OKST | DEC | Barney Cosneck ILL |
| Ambrose Rascher IND | — | Garrett Coleman NAVY |
| Ambrose Rascher IND | DEC | Barney Cosneck ILL |
| Semifinal | ||
| LeRoy McGuirk OKST | DEC | Ambrose Rascher IND |
| Joe Sintic OHIO | PIN 6:54 | Herb White Case-Western Reserve |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Ambrose Rascher IND | DEC | DeLoss Osborn Cornell College |
| Wes Brown NW | PIN 5:25 | Basil Alspaugh Denver |
| Robert Hess ISU | PIN 3:55 | Barney Cosneck ILL |