| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Hugh Linn ISU1st | DEC | Louis Bauerle ILL2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Norman Stoner MSU | — | |
| Grant Stein PSU |
| Norman Stoner MSU | — | Joe Fickel Kansas State |
| Sherman Stephenson OKST | — | George Field VMI |
| Louis Bauerle ILL | DEC | Norman Stoner MSU |
| Sherman Stephenson OKST | DEC | Norman Stoner MSU |
| Semifinal | ||
| Hugh Linn ISU | PIN 6:04 | Joe Fickel Kansas State |
| Louis Bauerle ILL | DEC | George Field VMI |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Hugh Linn ISU | DEC | Norman Stoner MSU |
| Louis Bauerle ILL | DEC | Sherman Stephenson OKST |
| George Field VMI | DEC | Bill Anderson CUSE |
| Joe Fickel Kansas State | PIN 5:59 | Edwin Belshaw IND |
| Pigtail | ||
| Sherman Stephenson OKST | DEC | Ralph Anderton BRWN |
| Hugh Linn ISU | PIN 7:55 | Grant Stein PSU |
| Norman Stoner MSU | PIN 7:19 | Kent Rochester Institute of Technology |