| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Laurance Mantooth OKLA1st | DEC | Matthew Hesser OKST2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Hyman Josefson COR | — | |
| David Holt WIS |
| Robert Hewitt MICH | — | Hyman Josefson COR |
| Robert Hewitt MICH | — | Matthew Hesser OKST |
| Semifinal | ||
| Laurance Mantooth OKLA | DEC | Robert Hewitt MICH |
| Matthew Hesser OKST | DEC | Richard Cole ISU |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Richard Cole ISU | DEC | Ralph Lupton NW |
| Laurance Mantooth OKLA | DEC | Hyman Josefson COR |
| Matthew Hesser OKST | PIN 5:39 | McMillon OHIO |
| Robert Hewitt MICH | DEFAULT | Vercoe OSU |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Richard Cole ISU | DEC | Ted Wilson PSU |
| Laurance Mantooth OKLA | DEC | David Holt WIS |
| Hyman Josefson COR | DEC | Himan University of Chicago |
| Robert Hewitt MICH | DEC | Stinson Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Matthew Hesser OKST | DEC | Henry Krakowski Case-Western Reserve |
| Ralph Lupton NW | DEC | Andes VT |