| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Justin Melick EMU | DEC 12-5 | Steven Johnson University of Findlay |
| Sidney Logan Indiana Institute of Technology | PIN | Eldin Hesselgrave Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Josh Johnson Lindsey Wilson College | TF 19-3 | Daniel Contreras Notre Dame College |
| Sam Viengmany Tiffin University | MAJ DEC 18-5 | Aaron Bullock Manchester University |
| Collin Poynter Indiana Institute of Technology | PIN | Mason Rickle Unattached |
| Joseph Johnson MSU | MAJ DEC 14-4 | Brent Browner Indiana Institute of Technology |
| Alex Gordon OSU | DEC 7-1 | Shane Justice Notre Dame College |
| Carter Augustyn Grand Valley State | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Steve Quinn WVU |