| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Chad Ryan COLU | PIN | Justin Kresevic OSU |
| Jake Kazimir COLU | PIN | Trevor Hartless EDIN |
| Jesse Freise Lindenwood-Belleville | DEC 6-4 | Kevin Brown COLU |
| Joe Cozart Lindsey Wilson College | DEC 10-4 | Kyle Witgen Olivet College |
| Markus Scheidel COLU | PIN | Matt Fee OSU |
| Andrew Romanchik OHIO | PIN | Jacob Gould Olivet College |
| Jesse Freise Lindenwood-Belleville | DEC 3-2 | Matt Pasqualini MSU |
| Trevor Hartless EDIN | DEC 3-1 | Isaac Morisette Lake Erie College |
| Brady Bersano California Baptist University | DEC 6-0 | Dakota Cooley CMU |
| Andrew Ermatinger MSU | DEC 10-3 | Zach Baumgartner EDIN |
| Brady Bersano California Baptist University | DEC 6-1 | Mike Migawa Calumet College of St. Joseph |
| Nathan Ball Lake Erie College | DEC 14-7 | Andrew Ermatinger MSU |
| Chad Ryan COLU | PIN | Daniel Luty CAMP |
| Markus Scheidel COLU | DEC 10-6 | Zack Johnson NAVY |