| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Kellen Russell MICH1st | DEC 5-2 | Scott Mattingly CMU2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Mitchell Port EDIN3rd | MAJ DEC 17-5 | Matt Ortega IND4th |
| Brandon Nelsen PUR5th | DEC 6-0 | Colin Shober NW6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Brandon Nelsen PUR | DEC 2-1 | Randy Languis OSU |
| Colin Shober NW | DEC 5-4 | Nick Lawrence PUR |
| Semifinal | ||
| Scott Mattingly CMU | DEC 6-3 | Matt Ortega IND |
| Kellen Russell MICH | DEC 4-0 | Mitchell Port EDIN |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Brandon Nelsen PUR | PIN | Matt Bystol COLU |
| Colin Shober NW | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Shawn Fayette NIU |
| Nick Lawrence PUR | DEC 6-5 | Marty Carlson Notre Dame College |
| Randy Languis OSU | DEC 7-2 | Darrin Boing OHIO |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Brandon Nelsen PUR | MAJ DEC 14-5 | Kenny Richmond Olivet College |
| Marty Carlson Notre Dame College | DEC 2-1 | Chris Andrews University of Findlay |
| Colin Shober NW | DEC 7-0 | Ryan McKenzie Tiffin University |
| Darrin Boing OHIO | DEC 6-2 | Casey Cruz UNCO |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Scott Mattingly CMU | DEC 2-1 | Randy Languis OSU |
| Matt Ortega IND | MAJ DEC 16-6 | Matt Bystol COLU |
| Kellen Russell MICH | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Shawn Fayette NIU |
| Mitchell Port EDIN | DEC 4-2 | Nick Lawrence PUR |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Chris Andrews University of Findlay | TF 16-0 | Corey Delaney IUPFW |
| Casey Cruz UNCO | DEC 7-3 | Seth Schaner EMU |
| Marty Carlson Notre Dame College | PIN | Pat Greco NW |
| Brandon Nelsen PUR | DEC 6-0 | Jacob Garringer Ashland University |
| Ryan McKenzie Tiffin University | MAJ DEC 13-5 | Chad Channel University of Findlay |
| Kenny Richmond Olivet College | DEC 3-2 | Matt Stanfield Cumberland University |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Nick Lawrence PUR | DEC 2-1 | Jacob Garringer Ashland University |
| Mitchell Port EDIN | TF 17-0 | Kenny Richmond Olivet College |
| Matt Bystol COLU | DEC 5-2 | Pat Greco NW |
| Shawn Fayette NIU | DEC 8-2 | Darrin Boing OHIO |
| Scott Mattingly CMU | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Ryan McKenzie Tiffin University |
| Kellen Russell MICH | MAJ DEC 13-0 | Seth Schaner EMU |
| Matt Ortega IND | PIN | Chris Andrews University of Findlay |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Shawn Fayette NIU | TF 15-0 | Corey Delaney IUPFW |
| Nick Lawrence PUR | DEC 5-3 | Colin Shober NW |
| Kenny Richmond Olivet College | DEC 6-0 | Chad Channel University of Findlay |
| Randy Languis OSU | DEC 8-3 | Brandon Nelsen PUR |
| Matt Bystol COLU | DEC 6-5 | Casey Cruz UNCO |
| Kellen Russell MICH | PIN | Marty Carlson Notre Dame College |
| Scott Mattingly CMU | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Matt Stanfield Cumberland University |