| Round of 16 |
| William Baysingar ILL | TF 15-0 | Vincent Sandoval Wayland Baptist (Texas) |
| Kody Ketchum Maryville University | PIN | Nik Petsinger Rochester Community and Technical College |
| Isaiah Perez Indian Hills Community College | PIN | Hudson Karr William Woods University |
| Sabian Russell Quincy | PIN | Shane Mobley-Koutsky Missouri Valley College |
| Sammy Shires Cumberland University | TF 16-1 | Andrew Larson Rochester Community and Technical College |
| AJ Rallo Bellarmine University | TF 15-0 | Gunnar LeGrand Lindenwood University |
| Nate Wishne William Jewell | TF 20-2 | Kason Mitchell Carl Albert State College |
| Jack Lage UCM | PIN | Caleb Andrews Ouachita Baptist University |
| Kalvin LaPlant Labette Community College | DEC 6-0 | Noah Abel Sierra College |
| Hudson Goebel ILL | DEC 4-2 | Chase Hall Bellarmine University |
| Jake Thompson Rochester Community and Technical College | PIN | Hayden Osment McKendree University |
| Paul Ishikawa Indian Hills Community College | PIN | Gabriel Moblicci Wayland Baptist (Texas) |
| Ashton Hayhurst Triton College | MAJ DEC 18-5 | Patrick Foxworth Cloud County Community College |
| Dailey Jennings University of Central Oklahoma | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Mitchell Borynack OKST |
| Jared Brown Marian University (Ind.) | PIN | Tiago Bertoldo Rochester Community and Technical College |
