| Consi 8 #1 |
| Conner Burrus University of the Cumberlands | PIN | Shane Mobley-Koutsky Missouri Valley College |
| Caleb Andrews Ouachita Baptist University | DEC 6-0 | Jesse Shannon Missouri Valley College |
| Ashton Massaro Triton College | TF 15-0 | Hudson Karr William Woods University |
| Dylan Reed Unattached | TF 19-4 | Nik Petsinger Rochester Community and Technical College |
| Vincent Sandoval Wayland Baptist (Texas) | DEC 8-6 | Trevon Swearinger Labette Community College |
| Blake Schmitt LIB | TF 15-0 | Kason Mitchell Carl Albert State College |
| Gunnar LeGrand Lindenwood University | PIN | Collin Smith Cloud County Community College |
| Andrew Larson Rochester Community and Technical College | PIN | Alexander Toro Wayland Baptist (Texas) |
| Tiago Bertoldo Rochester Community and Technical College | PIN | Joseph Kenny Missouri Valley College |
| Patrick Foxworth Cloud County Community College | DEC 20-15 | Luke Kawa Morton College |
| Mitchell Borynack OKST | PIN | Victor Salazar Quincy |
| Gabriel Moblicci Wayland Baptist (Texas) | PIN | Mason McClung University of the Cumberlands |
| Jazen Brown Labette Community College | TF 17-2 | Noah Abel Sierra College |
| Blaine Ortiz Missouri Valley College | PIN | Hayden Osment McKendree University |
| Chase Hall Bellarmine University | PIN | Owen Manley Quincy |
