| Round of 16 |
| Aundre Beatty Marian University (Ind.) | DEC 7-4 | Dalton Burdick Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College |
| Matty Bianchi UALR | PIN | Paul Pollard Drury University |
| William Tucker Triton College | PIN | Rufino Bustos Morton College |
| Cruz Lara Lindenwood University | PIN | Michael Crowder Avila University |
| Ronan Schuelke McKendree University | DEC 7-0 | Matthew Lewis Indian Hills Community College |
| Teague Travis OKST | MAJ DEC 18-6 | Raphael Marascio Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College |
| Kavan Troy NIU | PIN | Tucker Kinsaul Lindenwood University |
| Dylan Avery Unattached | DEC 6-3 | Donovan Parn Missouri Valley College |
| Joseph Rice Missouri Valley College | DEC 5-3 | Kobey Kizarr University of Central Oklahoma |
| Joseph Semerad McKendree University | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Troy Mock Triton College |
| Caleb Tyus SIUE | DEC 7-3 | Jeremy Jakowitsch MIZZ |
| Kalen Napier Lindenwood University | DEC 10-9 | Mitchell Huber Central Methodist University |
| Jake Harrier Lindenwood University | PIN | Lane White Avila University |
| Garrett Good LIB | PIN | Kaleb Talkington Cloud County Community College |
| Peter Rolle University of Central Oklahoma | PIN | Brett Parson Central Methodist University |
| Wyatt Henson IOWA | DEC 10-3 | Cooper Evans Carl Albert State College |
