| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Crossover | ||
| Michael Kistler PENN | PIN | Thomas LaScala Long Island University |
| Brian Meyer LEH | DEC 2-1 | Lucas Revano PENN |
| Brandon Connor MVILLE | DEC 4-3 | Doak Dean HARV |
| Alex Farenchak Gannon University | DEC 10-5 | Ashton Eyler LHU |
| Noah Grover BUFF | DEC 2-1 | Jay Nivison BUFF |
| Dalton Harkins ARMY | PIN | Tracy Hubbard CMU |
| Guy DeLeonardis MVILLE | TF 20-3 | Aladeen Hussein SHU |
| Dillon Keane PITT | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Ryan Bolletino SHU |
| Clayton Fielden | ||
| DEC 2-1 |
| Brinton Simington LHU |
| Alex Jacobs CMU | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Kyle Matthews Long Island University |
| Cam Connor PENN | DEC 2-0 | Alex Whitworth HARV |
| Christian Hunt ARMY | DEC 11-5 | Jake Stefanowicz PENN |
| James Romaine College of New Jersey | DEC 3-2 | Blake Bahna Long Island University |
| Matthew Olguin ORST | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Connor Herceg LEH |
| Matt Surich College of New Jersey | PIN | Roy Scherer SHU |
| Job Chishko VMI | DEC 10-4 | Joe Metz ARMY |
| Nicolas Eboli SHU | PIN | Gavin Hale BLOOM |