| Cons. Round 2 |
| Zane Stoddard San Francisco Wrestling Club | DEC 6-2 | Richard Mack III Unattached |
| Cody Harrison Scarlet Knights Wrestling Club | DEC 11-2 | Michael Martinak Pennsylvania RTC |
| Bretli Reyna Hawkeye Wrestling Club | DEC 17-13 | Joshua Ogunsanya New York City RTC |
| Trey Kruse Boilermaker RTC | DEC 8-4 | Tristan Pugh Young Guns |
| Nate Stokhaug Unattached | PIN 5-0 | Adam Thebeau BullTrained Wrestling |
| Ryan Vulakh Scarlet Knights Wrestling Club | TF 10-0 | Bryce Hampton Unattached |
| Warren Carr Wyoming Wrestling RTC | DEC 10-1 | Zeb Gnida Dubuque Wrestling Club |
| Kyle Mosher New York City RTC | TF 10-0 | Sonny Santiago Unattached |
| Aaden Valdez La Gente Wrestling Club | DEC 11-4 | Thomas Askey Unattached |
| Weston Wichman Unattached | PIN 6-0 | Kirill Chirva Choker Wrestling Club |
| Jaxon Garoutte Brunson UVRTC | DEC 14-6 | Mitchell Bohlken Tiger Style Wrestling Club |
| Anthony Herrera Mustang Wrestling Club | DEC 2-1 | Jeremy Ridge Pennsylvania RTC |
| Walker Heard Mountaineer Wrestling Club | DEC 7-6 | Jack Lang Unattached |
| Antonio Petrucelli Pittsburgh Wrestling Club | TF 10-0 | Nolan Miller-Johnston MWC Wrestling Academy |
| John Richardson Texas Pride Wrestling Club | DEC 8-4 | Ridge Briggs Wyoming Wrestling RTC |
| Carter Schmidt Cyclone RTC C-RTC | DEC 4-2 | Gabriel Fiser Dubuque Wrestling Club |
