| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Paul Carson APP | DEC 6-4 | Aaron Naples OHIO |
| Rodney Jones CHAT | DEC 3-1 | Anthony DePrez BING |
| Sawyer Root CIT | DEC 7-3 | Michael Bulkin COLU |
| Eli Spencer GMU | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Sam Wustefeld COLU |
| Stephen Loiseau DREX | TF 18-2 | Josh Loomer CSUB |
| Ethan Laird RIDER | PIN | Kaden Sauer ISU |
| Dylan Reynolds EDIN | TF 17-1 | Jack Trautman III GWU |
| Bo Nickal PSU | PIN | Tyrie Houghton NCST |
| Luke McGonigal LHU | PIN | Demazio Samuel APP |
| Joshua Roetman NAVY | PIN | Jared Johnson CHAT |
| Nathan Traxler STAN | TF 16-0 | Nate Hall OHIO |
| Dakota Geer OKST | TF 15-0 | Alec Schenk DUKE |
| Tom Sleigh VT | DEC 2-0 | Anthony Perrine GWU |
| Randall Diabe APP | MAJ DEC 14-3 | Mark Chaid UNC |