| Round of 32 |
| Matt Ortiz IND | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Oswald Hountondji MacMurray College |
| Isaiah Newberry Lindsey Wilson College | DEC 5-3 | Jonathan Vizcarrondo Williams Baptist College |
| Jon Trowbridge Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College | PIN | Jared Givens Williams Baptist College |
| Joe Scott LIB | TF 16-0 | John Lee Lindsey Wilson College |
| Ismael Cornejo Marian University (Ind.) | TF 18-0 | William Gaither Williams Baptist College |
| Cory Peterson McKendree University | MAJ DEC 19-10 | Zach Russel Lindenwood University |
| Caleb Long ISU | PIN | Nolan Saale Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College |
| Cameron Butler Lindsey Wilson College | TF 15-0 | Nosa Johnbull Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College |
| Vincent (Elijah) Cherry Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College | PIN | Cameron Ward Lindsey Wilson College |
