| Round of 32 |
| Carter Schmidt ISU | PIN | Derek Nicks Davenport University |
| Thomas Schock Spartanburg Methodist College | DEC 10-4 | Korbin Riedel UALR |
| Ryan Swanson | MAJ DEC 13-3 | Charles Getz McKendree University |
| Joseph Sanchez IND | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Eric Owens ISU |
| Keith Clay Williams Baptist College | DEC 10-8 | Adam Blonski Joliet Junior College |
| Brooks Davis Marian University (Ind.) | TF 16-1 | Austin Zaring Labette Community College |
| Tyson Smith Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College | PIN | Robbie Snellingberger McKendree University |
| Jake Reicin ILL | DEC 9-8 | Ben Courtney McKendree University |
| Joe Koontz Lindsey Wilson College | DEC 6-1 | Mikael Failor Ellsworth Community College |
| Anthony Michaels Lindenwood University | TF 16-0 | Matt Burns Marian University (Ind.) |
| Cooper Siebrecht Minnesota State | TF 19-1 | Will Keener Kentucky Wesleyan College |
| Vernell Hawkins Labette Community College | DEC 5-3 | Carlos Mora Newman University |
| Chance McLane OKST | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Brody Nielsen Minnesota State |
| Trevor South Kentucky Wesleyan College | DEC 8-7 | Jose Sanchez MacMurray College |
| Jacob Warren Westminster | PIN | Adam Brinkman Marian University (Ind.) |
| Austin Landow Lindenwood University | DEC 6-4 | Justin Maynard Ellsworth Community College |
