| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Crossover | ||
| Zahid Valencia ASU | DEC 8-7 | Taylor Venz NEB |
| Trevor Allard BLOOM | DEC 6-5 | Dylan Ammerman LEH |
| Darrien Roberts OKLA | DEC 7-5 | Jake Hinz IND |
| Antonio Agee ODU | DEC 8-2 | Ruston Duke OKLA |
| Billy Janzer Unattached | FORFEIT | Corey Hazel LHU |
| Christopher Weiler LEH | DEC 6-1 | Tanner Orndorff UVU |
| David Heath BRWN | DEC 3-2 | Noah Baughman ODU |
| Gary Jantzer UVU | FORFEIT | Charles Small HOF |
| Paul Pierce GMU | PIN | |
| Lachlan Rosato DAV |
| Round Robin 5 | ||
| Connor Craig PITT-J | FORFEIT | Dan McClure Long Island University |
| Austin Clayton ASU | FORFEIT | Francis Rossi Unattached |
| Round Robin 4 | ||
| Ray Bernot LHU | PIN | Francis Rossi Unattached |
| Austin Clayton ASU | FORFEIT | Dan McClure Long Island University |
| Round Robin 3 | ||
| Darrien Roberts OKLA | PIN | Lachlan Rosato DAV |
| Austin Clayton ASU | DEC 10-7 | Ray Bernot LHU |
| Zahid Valencia ASU | PIN | Tanner Orndorff UVU |
| Antonio Agee ODU | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Gary Jantzer UVU |
| Connor Craig PITT-J | TF 16-0 | Francis Rossi Unattached |
| Taylor Venz NEB | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Corey Hazel LHU |
| Jake Hinz IND | DEC 8-4 | Noah Baughman ODU |
| Ruston Duke OKLA | FORFEIT | Charles Small HOF |
| Round Robin 2 | ||
| Dan McClure Long Island University | MAJ DEC 12-0 | Francis Rossi Unattached |
| Tanner Orndorff UVU | DEC 2-1 | Billy Janzer Unattached |
| Connor Craig PITT-J | TF 16-1 | Ray Bernot LHU |
| Dylan Ammerman LEH | PIN | Antonio Agee ODU |
| David Heath BRWN | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Lachlan Rosato DAV |
| Trevor Allard BLOOM | DEC 10-4 | Ruston Duke OKLA |
| Jake Hinz IND | DEC 9-3 | Paul Pierce GMU |
| Christopher Weiler LEH | PIN | Corey Hazel LHU |
| Round Robin 1 | ||
| Dylan Ammerman LEH | PIN | Gary Jantzer UVU |
| Darrien Roberts OKLA | DEC 2-0 | David Heath BRWN |
| Connor Craig PITT-J | DEC 10-3 | Austin Clayton ASU |
| Noah Baughman ODU | DEC 3-2 | Paul Pierce GMU |
| Zahid Valencia ASU | TF 19-4 | Billy Janzer Unattached |
| Dan McClure Long Island University | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Ray Bernot LHU |
| Taylor Venz NEB | PIN | Christopher Weiler LEH |
| Trevor Allard BLOOM | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Charles Small HOF |