| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round Robin | ||
| Timothy Nagosky Long Island University | DEC 5-2 | Colton Crane BUFF |
| Seth Janney COR | TF 16-1 | Maguire Horl Long Island University |
| Brendan Furman COR | DEC 4-0 | Paul Robinson ARMY |
| Lewis Fernandes Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | PIN | Imani Heslop Presbyterian College |
| Timothy Nagosky Long Island University | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Will Pontoon Presbyterian College |
| Gregory Hodulick BUFF | PIN | Maguire Horl Long Island University |
| Paul Robinson ARMY | PIN | Will Pontoon Presbyterian College |
| Gregory Hodulick BUFF | DEC 4-3 | Imani Heslop Presbyterian College |
| Paul Robinson ARMY | PIN | Colton Crane BUFF |
| Imani Heslop Presbyterian College | DEFAULT | Seth Janney COR |
| Brendan Furman COR | PIN | Timothy Nagosky Long Island University |
| Lewis Fernandes Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | PIN | Maguire Horl Long Island University |
| Brendan Furman COR | PIN | Colton Crane BUFF |
| Colton Crane BUFF | DEC 9-7 | Will Pontoon Presbyterian College |
| Seth Janney COR | TF 19-3 | Gregory Hodulick BUFF |
| Paul Robinson ARMY | DEC 6-2 | Timothy Nagosky Long Island University |
| Imani Heslop Presbyterian College | DEC 5-3 | Maguire Horl Long Island University |
| Brendan Furman COR | PIN | Will Pontoon Presbyterian College |
| Lewis Fernandes Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | DEC 5-0 | Seth Janney COR |
| Lewis Fernandes Finger Lakes Wrestling Club | FORFEIT | Gregory Hodulick BUFF |