| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round Robin | ||
| Bennett Paulson ARMY | PIN | Daniel Shafran Long Island University |
| Jonathan Loew COR | PIN | Montgomery Mills Presbyterian College |
| Daniel Shafran Long Island University | PIN | Jacob Harrison SHU |
| Jonathan Loew COR | PIN | Daniel Shafran Long Island University |
| Samuel Mitchell BUFF | PIN | Montgomery Mills Presbyterian College |
| Bennett Paulson ARMY | TF 18-0 | Jacob Harrison SHU |
| Samuel Mitchell BUFF | DEC 7-4 | Austin Stith Presbyterian College |
| Bennett Paulson ARMY | TF 17-2 | Montgomery Mills |
| Austin Stith Presbyterian College | MAJ DEC 15-7 | Jacob Harrison SHU |
| Jonathan Loew COR | TF 16-1 | Austin Stith Presbyterian College |
| Bennett Paulson ARMY | DEC 12-5 | Samuel Mitchell BUFF |
| Jonathan Loew COR | PIN | Samuel Mitchell BUFF |
| Bennett Paulson ARMY | TF 18-0 | Austin Stith Presbyterian College |
| Samuel Mitchell BUFF | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Jacob Harrison SHU |
| Jonathan Loew COR | TF 21-6 | Jacob Harrison SHU |
| Austin Stith Presbyterian College | DEC 8-3 | Daniel Shafran Long Island University |
| Jacob Harrison SHU | PIN | Montgomery Mills Presbyterian College |
| Austin Stith Presbyterian College | DEC 10-5 | Montgomery Mills Presbyterian College |
| Samuel Mitchell BUFF | DEC 7-0 | Daniel Shafran Long Island University |
| Daniel Shafran Long Island University | DEC 6-3 | Montgomery Mills Presbyterian College |
| Jonathan Loew COR | DEC 7-4 | Bennett Paulson ARMY |