| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round Robin | ||
| Chas Tucker COR | PIN | Tommy Maddox BUFF |
| Jim Wilson COR | PIN | Jason Javier BING |
| Anthony Petrillo SHU | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Brandon Loperfido LHU |
| Anthony Petrillo SHU | DEC 6-2 | Alfonso DeRosa BING |
| Chas Tucker COR | DEC 9-3 | Ryan Hetrick ARMY |
| Jim Wilson COR | PIN | Khalid Brinkley Presbyterian College |
| Ryan Hetrick ARMY | DEC 9-2 | Tommy Maddox BUFF |
| Alfonso DeRosa BING | FORFEIT | Brandon Loperfido LHU |
| Phillip Moomey | ||
| PIN |
| Michael Blando Long Island University |
| Phillip Moomey COR | PIN | Parker Corwin Presbyterian College |
| Parker Corwin Presbyterian College | PIN | Michael Blando Long Island University |
| Jason Javier BING | DEC 12-9 | Khalid Brinkley Presbyterian College |